‘If we don’t have that social licence, we are going to die’: So You Are fallout continues as another historic trophy is stolen

Channel 7’s Jason Richardson on the So You Are aftermath and the theft of the 1948 Caulfield Cup, Cambridge Stud’s Henry Plumptre on a systemic welfare failure, and the BHA’s James Given on what happens in Britain.

Nick Luck Daily

So You Are after a race in Australia

The fallout from the So You Are affair will reverberate around racing worldwide, says Channel 7’s Jason Richardson, as a second high-profile theft hit Melbourne racing and a leading figure in Australasian bloodstock warned that the sport’s future is at stake.

So You Are, the Bjorn Baker-trained Bendigo Cup winner who ran in the Melbourne Cup, was euthanised after a severe colic on Monday, and footage then emerged of his remains in a skip at a Sydney waste facility. “We’re on the back of an incredible spring racing carnival where everyone was so buoyant, and so excited about the future of racing in Victoria and New South Wales,” Richardson told Nick Luck. “Somehow, through the protocols of getting So You Are’s body to an appropriate burial with the respect he so richly deserves, there’s been a breakdown in the chain of custody, and he’s ended up in a rubbish bin. That has raised so many concerns about how we treat our livestock and our deadstock. There will be massive reverberations across every part of the industry, not just here in Australia but around the world.”

“In my gut, I don’t think the racing industry has done anything wrong,” he added. “He went to the vet clinic, and somehow, through their systems, this has happened. Now everyone is trying to justify it. It’s just horrible.”

The 1948 Caulfield Cup stolen

Days after Makybe Diva’s three Melbourne Cups were taken from Flemington, it has emerged that the 1948 Caulfield Cup, won by Red Fury, has been stolen from its display at Caulfield. “You just shake your head,” Richardson said. “Whether it’s got the same value for melting down, I would doubt, but it’s got incredible historic value. It was a solid nine-carat gold trophy.” The Melbourne Racing Club has said police are investigating.

Richardson fears Makybe Diva’s Cups are gone for good. “I think the four most iconic Melbourne Cup trophies would be Makybe Diva’s three and Phar Lap’s,” he said. “And we now know that when they investigated the gold in the 1980 Melbourne Cup, Beldale Ball’s, owned by Robert Sangster, it was basically a rehash of Phar Lap’s 1930 Cup. So we don’t have Phar Lap’s Cup any more, and now we won’t have Makybe Diva’s three.”

“That’s the only thing in the next 20 years which is going to give us a social licence. If we don’t have that social licence, we are going to die.”

Henry Plumptre

Plumptre: ‘A systemic failure of the regulators’

Henry Plumptre, chief executive of Cambridge Stud in New Zealand and a former managing director of Godolphin in Australia, speaking personally, said later in the programme that racing is not getting on top of welfare. “We are reminded that we’re not getting on top of it probably annually, by an event such as what happened in New South Wales,” he said. “I think it’s a systemic failure of the regulators of the various states in Australia, and indeed perhaps in New Zealand, and the reason is that the regulators and the governments in charge of them are not taking it seriously enough.”

He singled out Racing NSW. “You have a regulatory body which, in its published accounts, is sitting on top of $400 million. It’s got one of the highest prize-money totals per capita in the world, but it cannot get on top of its welfare issue,” he said. “There hasn’t been a regulatory framework put in place to support the welfare of horses after racing, during racing, and the euthanasing of racehorses after catastrophic injury. All of that should be absolutely prime time. It should be the number one thing on our agenda, because that’s the only thing in the next 20 years which is going to give us a social licence. If we don’t have that social licence, we are going to die.”

What happens in Britain

James Given, the BHA’s director of equine regulation, safety and welfare, explained later in the show that the same situation could not arise in Britain. “The disposal of carcasses is governed by UK legislation,” he said. “If a horse is euthanised by veterinary lethal injection, those carcasses can only be incinerated or rendered, so they need to go to specialist facilities. It absolutely couldn’t go into landfill, as I believe has happened in Australia.”

Burial rules differ across the three nations. “In England, a horse kept as a pet or working on a farm may be buried on private land, subject to Environment Agency groundwater rules. In Scotland and Wales, only pet horses may be buried on private land,” Given said. “But it’s not for horses involved in our sport.” He added that, so far, racing had not encountered a situation in Britain where carcasses could not be disposed of properly.