
Hear the full interview
From 32:58 in Monday’s episode of Nick Luck Daily. Press play to start at the interview.
Makybe Diva’s three Melbourne Cup trophies have been stolen from Flemington, in what Racing.com’s Michael Felgate says will go down as one of the most significant stories in racing history if they are not recovered.
The cups, won in 2003, 2004 and 2005, were taken on Monday morning, Australian time. Owner Tony Santic had lent them to the Victoria Racing Club, and they had been on public display at the racecourse since September. Felgate, host of Racing.com’s The Verdict podcast, told Nick Luck that the alleged thieves were dressed as workmen. “Three alleged thieves dressed as workmen, wearing hi-vis gear, walked into Flemington Racecourse and went into the grandstand where the Makybe Diva display was,” he said. “They broke the glass casing that the three cups were held in and stole her three Melbourne Cups.”
Victoria Police said they were investigating a burglary and theft at Flemington, and that the circumstances were yet to be established.
‘Irreplaceable’ and worth millions in gold
Makybe Diva remains the only horse to win the Melbourne Cup three years in a row. “She is the most iconic horse we’ve had in the modern era of Australian racing, and we are probably never going to see that again,” Felgate said. “These are iconic parts of Australian racing history, but they’re also extremely valuable. We all know what the price of gold is at the moment. This year’s Melbourne Cup trophy alone was worth in excess of a million dollars because of the price of gold, so we’re talking maybe close to three million dollars just to replace these. But they are priceless from a racing history point of view.”
“How can three people walk into Flemington and steal three of the most important trophies in Australian racing history?”
Michael Felgate
Santic, who spoke about the theft on 3AW, is devastated, Felgate said. “He was due to get the three cups back from the VRC next week,” he said. “Questions will now be asked. How the hell has this occurred? What security was in place? And how can three people walk into Flemington and steal three of the most important trophies in Australian racing history?”
He said the VRC had issued a measured statement saying it was devastated and cooperating fully with police. “I would hope the area was covered by CCTV and that we’ll see some images, but at this stage none of that has come to light,” he said. “This is extremely embarrassing for the Victoria Racing Club. It’s devastating for the racing industry as a whole. And can you imagine, if you’re Tony Santic, what you’d be going through right now?”
‘The power of a hi-vis vest’
Lydia Hislop, Nick’s guest on the programme, felt for Santic after such a generous gesture. “It’s just a reminder of how gullible we are as human beings, and the power of a hi-vis vest,” she said. “It’s been shown time after time that things like that mean people become invisible, implicitly trusted. I do hope I’m wrong, but I don’t feel hopeful about the recovery of these trophies, given the price of gold these days and the sophistication of the networks that can move these things away very quickly. I feel so sorry that an act of generosity has ended like this.”



